Money Basics

Shoppers Are 'Trading Down' This Holiday. What Is That?

News reports say shoppers are trading down more than they have in years, right as holiday shopping begins. Trading down means picking a cheaper version of something you still want. Learn why families do it, how to tell a real deal with unit price math, and how to run a blind taste test at home.

Foundra Kids·8 min read
Shoppers Are 'Trading Down' This Holiday. What Is That?

Picture the cereal aisle. On one shelf sits the famous box with the cartoon mascot. Say it costs $5.49. Right beside it sits a plain box from the store's own brand. Same kind of cereal. It costs $3.29.

Which one goes in the cart?

If your family grabs the cheaper box, you just did something that has a name. It's called trading down. And right now, a whole lot of people are doing it.

On November 16, the business magazine Fortune reported that shoppers are trading down more than they have in years. The report used card spending data from Bank of America, a very large bank. It landed right before the busiest shopping weeks of the year.

So what is trading down? Why is everyone doing it? And is the cheaper thing always the smarter pick? Let's find out.

What does trading down mean?

Trading down means choosing a less expensive version of something you still want or need.

Notice what it doesn't mean. It doesn't mean buying nothing. You still get cereal. You just get a different box.

Here are some ways families trade down:

  • Buying the store brand instead of the famous brand
  • Eating at a burger place instead of a sit-down restaurant
  • Shopping for clothes at a discount store
  • Taking a road trip instead of flying somewhere far away
  • Buying a used bike instead of a new one

Fortune says the bank found this happening with clothes, eating out, groceries and travel.

Here's a twist. The bank also said trading down doesn't always mean people spend less money overall. Lots of shoppers are changing where and how they spend. The dollars move around.

There's an opposite, too. Trading up is when you pick a fancier version. People do both, sometimes on the same day! A family might buy plain cereal and then splurge on a great birthday cake.

Why are people trading down now?

The biggest reason is that things cost more than they used to.

When prices go up across lots of stuff at once, it's called inflation. Fortune reported that prices in the United States were up about 3.6 percent from a year earlier, based on government data.

What does 3.6 percent feel like? Imagine a basket of snacks that cost $10.00 last November. This November, that same basket costs about $10.36. Thirty-six cents doesn't sound like much. But now stretch it across everything a family buys in a year: food, gas, shoes, heat, school supplies. It adds up fast.

And here's the hard part. When prices rise faster than paychecks, families have to make choices. They can buy fewer things. Or they can buy cheaper versions of the same things. Trading down is that second choice.

It's not a sad thing or an embarrassing thing. It's a tool. Smart shoppers use it on purpose.

Wait, is holiday spending going up or down?

Up! Which sounds strange, so let's untangle it.

A group called the National Retail Federation studies stores and shoppers. It predicts Americans will spend about $1.013 trillion in November and December. That's 4.2 percent more than last year's $972 billion.

A trillion is a 1 with twelve zeros. It's a thousand billions.

So people are spending more and hunting for cheaper stuff? Yes. Here's how both can be true.

Fortune shared an estimate from Mastercard that about half of this season's growth comes from higher prices. In other words, part of that extra spending isn't extra presents. It's the same presents with bigger price tags.

Spending more dollars isn't the same as getting more things. That's one of the most useful money ideas you'll ever learn.

Another study, from a company called Deloitte, found the average household plans to spend $1,654 on the holidays. That's up from $1,595 last year.

Who are the value seekers?

Deloitte asked 4,000 shoppers about their plans. It found that 38 percent of them are what it calls holiday value seekers.

A value seeker is a shopper who works to get more for each dollar. They wait for sales. They use reward points. They pick store brands.

Now for the surprise. Value seekers plan to spend 12 percent more than other shoppers.

How can that be? Because being careful isn't the same as being stingy. A value seeker saves $2 on cereal so there's more money for a gift that matters. They're not spending less. They're aiming better.

Deloitte also found that two groups of younger grown-ups, called Gen Z and millennials, will make up half of all holiday spending for the first time. Gen Z includes teens and young adults. Many of today's parents are millennials.

Mastercard surveyed 9,034 adults around the world and found that these younger shoppers love a bargain:

  • 84 percent want low-cost gifts that still feel special
  • 78 percent plan to do most of their buying on big sale days
  • 72 percent plan to buy secondhand gifts as often as before, or more

Is the cheaper one always the better deal?

Nope. And this is where a little math makes you powerful.

Trick one: check the unit price. The unit price tells you how much you pay for each ounce, each sheet or each piece. You find it by dividing the price by the amount.

Say a 12-ounce box of crackers costs $3.00. Divide $3.00 by 12. That's 25 cents an ounce. A bigger 18-ounce box costs $4.14. Divide $4.14 by 18. That's 23 cents an ounce.

The big box has the higher price tag but the lower unit price. If your family will eat all of it, the big box wins. Many stores print the unit price in tiny numbers on the shelf label. Go look next time!

Trick two: think about cost per use. A $20 pair of sneakers that falls apart in 4 months costs $5 a month. A $45 pair that lasts a whole year costs $3.75 a month. The pricier pair is the better deal.

So trading down smartly doesn't mean grabbing the lowest sticker. It means asking, "What am I getting for each dollar?"

Try it: run a blind taste test

Are famous brands better, or do we just think they are? Test it like a scientist.

You'll need: two versions of the same food (one name brand, one store brand), small cups, sticky notes, and a helper.

  1. Ask your helper to pour each food into cups while you look away.
  2. Have them label the cups A and B, and write down secretly which is which.
  3. Taste both. Sip water in between.
  4. Score each one from 1 to 5.
  5. Have a few family members do the same thing.
  6. Reveal the answer!

Now do the money part. Write down each price. If the store brand costs $2.20 less and your family buys that food once a week, how much would you save in a year? There are 52 weeks, so $2.20 times 52 is $114.40.

Sometimes the famous brand wins the taste test. That's fine. Then you know it's worth paying extra for. Either way, you chose with facts and not with a mascot.

What does this mean if you sell things?

If you're planning a booth at a holiday craft fair, this news is about your customers.

Lots of shoppers are watching every dollar this season. They still want to buy gifts. They just want to feel good about the price. So think like they do.

  • Have one low-priced item. A $2 or $3 choice lets everyone buy something.
  • Offer a bundle. "One for $2, three for $5" makes customers feel clever, and you sell more.
  • Show the value. A little sign that says "Handmade, takes 40 minutes each" tells people why your price is fair.
  • Don't race to the bottom. If you charge less than your supplies cost, you lose money on every sale.

Grown-up business owners think about this all the time. They ask who their customers are and what those customers can afford. Some plan it out on paper, and some use planning tools like Foundra to work through pricing before they open.

You can plan it on the back of an envelope. What matters is that you thought about the shopper first.

Key takeaways

  • Trading down means choosing a cheaper version of something you still want.
  • Reports this week say shoppers are trading down more than they have in years.
  • Inflation, when prices rise across many things, is a big reason.
  • Holiday spending is still expected to top $1 trillion, partly because prices are higher.
  • Value seekers hunt for deals so they can spend on what matters most.
  • Unit price and cost per use help you spot a real deal.

Frequently asked questions

What is trading down? It's when a shopper picks a less expensive version of a product or service, like a store brand instead of a famous brand.

What is a store brand? It's a product made for and sold by the store itself. Store brands usually cost less because the store spends less on advertising them.

What is inflation? Inflation is when prices for many things go up over time, so each dollar buys a little less than it did before.

How do I find the unit price? Divide the price by the amount. A $3.00 box with 12 ounces costs 25 cents per ounce. Many stores also print it on the shelf tag.

Is it bad to buy the cheaper brand? Not at all. Many store brands taste the same or nearly the same. A blind taste test at home can help your family decide which ones are worth it.

Why are people spending more if they are trading down? Higher prices push the total up even when shoppers pick cheaper options. Many people also save in one place so they can spend in another.

Sources

Ready to help a young entrepreneur get started?

Foundra Kids gives young founders a simple, fun way to plan their first business.

Try Foundra Kids

More to explore